Sales Play

Dec 01, 2026

Planned Unused Credits: Breakage Is a Finance Call, Not a Sales One

Idea in Brief

The Problem. When a customer commits to more credits than they use, the unused money can look like a win. Some deals are even priced counting on it.

Why It Matters. Breakage changes when revenue is recognized, and it is revenue that won't come back next year. The customer pays for it too: every unused credit raises the price they paid for the credits they did use.

The Fix. Size the commit to real usage, don't sell on breakage, and leave the breakage estimate to finance.

What Breakage Is

Start with a gift card. You buy a $100 gift card and only ever spend $60 of it. The store keeps the other $40. Accountants call that $40 breakage: money a customer paid for rights they never used.

Usage-based contracts work the same way. The customer commits to a set amount of credits, often paid or billed up front. If they use fewer credits than they bought, and the unused credits expire with no refund, the seller keeps the money for the unused part. That is breakage.

Breakage = Commit − Usage, for each period in which unused credits expire with no refund (zero if usage exceeds the commit)

Take a customer who commits to $100K of credits for the year and uses $60K. If the unused credits expire at year end, breakage is $40K.

When Breakage Happens, and When It Doesn't

Breakage needs three things:

  • The customer uses less than the commit in a period. In other words, coverage is below 1.0 for that period. (Coverage is usage divided by commit. See Underpriced Minimums.) Watch the period: if credits are granted monthly, a slow month can create breakage even when the customer clears the commit over the year.
  • The unused credits expire. If they roll over, the seller still owes them, and the revenue generally stays deferred longer (see Rollovers).
  • There is no refund. If unused credits must be refunded, the money was never the seller's. It is a liability owed back to the customer, not revenue.

Two more cases that look like breakage but aren't:

  • A shortfall fee billed later. Some contracts bill the customer at the end of the term for the gap between the commit and their usage. That is a different arrangement, and how it is recognized depends on the contract. It also brings a risk breakage doesn't: collecting the money.
  • Money owed to a government. In some places, unclaimed-property laws require unused balances to be handed over to the state. Amounts that must be handed over are a liability, not breakage.

When Breakage Becomes Revenue (the Finance View)

This part is mostly for your finance partner, but it is worth knowing. The cash arrives when the customer pays. The revenue does not. Under the accounting rules most software companies follow (ASC 606), Deloitte's guidance is direct: companies "should not recognize breakage as revenue immediately upon the receipt of payment." Instead, there are two ways to recognize it:

  1. Gradually, as the customer uses credits. If finance expects some credits to go unused, and can estimate how many without a significant risk of having to reverse that revenue later, it recognizes the expected breakage a little at a time, in step with the credits the customer uses. In practice, finance usually needs a history across many similar contracts to support an estimate like this.
  2. All at once, when it becomes remote that the rest will be used. If finance can't estimate it with that confidence, it waits until it is remote, a very high bar, that the customer will ever use the remaining credits. Often that is when they expire.

Here is the same $100K deal both ways. The customer uses $60K over the year.

  • Method 1: gradual. Finance expects 40% of credits to go unused. So for every $1 of credits the customer uses, finance recognizes $1 ÷ (1 − 0.40) = $1.67 of the prepaid $100K as revenue. The customer isn't billed any more. By year end, $60K of usage has brought in the full $100K of revenue.
  • Method 2: at expiry. The seller recognizes $60K as the credits are used, then the remaining $40K when they expire at year end.

Either way, the total is $100K. What changes is when it lands. Deloitte makes the same point: breakage "does not affect the transaction price." It is about timing. Finance also updates its estimate each period, so if the customer starts using more, less breakage is recognized.

Deloitte's own example uses a gift certificate with a 20% expected breakage rate: every $1 redeemed brings in $1.25. This is a plain-English summary, not accounting advice. Your finance team and auditors decide how your contracts are recognized.

The Customer's Side: Breakage Is a Price Increase

Breakage looks like found money to the seller. To the customer, it is a higher price.

Effective price per credit used = Committed rate ÷ Coverage (when coverage is below 1.0)

Say list price is $1.00 a credit and the customer's committed rate is $0.80. They commit to $100K, which buys 125,000 credits, and use 75,000. Their coverage is 0.6. They effectively paid $0.80 ÷ 0.6 = $1.33 for every credit they used. That is more than list price, the price they would have paid with no commit at all.

A quick check: if coverage falls below (1 − the discount), the customer is paying more than list for what they use. With a 20% discount, that line is 0.8.

Customers notice. At renewal, they cut the commit, ask for a refund or rollover, or leave. In each case, the breakage doesn't repeat.

Why Sales Shouldn't Plan on It

"Planned breakage" means pricing a deal on the assumption that some credits will go unused. It is tempting: a bigger commit looks better today, and the unused part becomes revenue later.

But breakage is lumpy, one-time revenue. MongoDB showed this at scale. On its Q1 FY25 call, CFO Michael Gordon said growth would be "impacted by the absence of over $40 million in revenue related to unused customer commitments" recognized the year before. MongoDB had already de-emphasized upfront commitments in its sales incentives, and that revenue didn't come back the next year.

That points to a common cause of planned breakage: the comp plan. If reps are paid on commit size, they are paid to oversize commits. Fix the comp plan, not just the policy.

Two more risks sit with sales:

  • Side promises. A rep saying "don't worry, they'll roll over" can create a right the customer can enforce, even if the contract says otherwise. That can undo finance's breakage estimate.
  • The renewal. A commit sized for breakage is a commit sized too big, and the customer finds out at renewal.

So the roles should be clear:

  • Sales sizes the commit to expected usage, aiming for coverage of about 1.0 to 1.3.
  • Finance owns the breakage estimate. It is a judgment that moves reported revenue, so it belongs with the people accountable for reported revenue, not with whoever closed the deal.

When Some Breakage Is Fine

Some breakage is normal. Customers don't use every credit, and expiry is the market default for good reasons. The problem isn't breakage. It's a deal that only works if the customer wastes credits.

Where AI Helps

The warning signs show up long before the renewal. With usage data and coverage targets built into the playbook, AI can flag a proposed commit whose expected coverage is below 1.0 before the quote goes out, and track coverage on live contracts so the account team sees a breakage risk while there is still time to act.

Try it this week: list your contracts with coverage below 1.0 in their most recent period. For each, calculate the customer's effective price per credit used: committed rate divided by coverage. Any that come out above list price are the renewals most at risk.

Close the Loop

Once a quarter, compare breakage with renewals:

  • How much breakage did you recognize, and from which customers?
  • Did those customers renew, and at what commit?
  • Is breakage concentrated in one segment, product or rep?

If breakage keeps coming from the same places, commits there are being sized too big.

Vantage Point

A large unused balance usually gets noticed at renewal, when it's too late to fix. In the deals we see at Revolear, the warning sign is usually visible at signing: the expected coverage was below 1.0.

The Takeaway

Breakage is the money a seller keeps when prepaid credits expire unused. It changes when revenue lands, not the price of the contract, and it rarely repeats. The customer pays for it with a higher effective price. Size the commit to usage, let finance own the estimate, and watch coverage.

Related in this series: this post is part of the Usage-Based Contracting series on credit pricing guardrails. Read more from the series:

Underpriced Minimums: The Hidden Cost of a Small Commitment

Overage Discounts: Why Cheaper Excess Undermines Renewals

Rollovers, Expiry, and Refundability: The Terms That Move Revenue

Which Credit-Pricing Terms Need Approval? A Discount Authority Matrix

The Deal Desk Glossary

Raja Singh is the Founder & CEO of Revolear, the AI deal desk that runs your commercial playbook on every deal.

Sources: Deloitte DART 8.8, Customers' Unexercised Rights (Breakage) · PwC Viewpoint, Unexercised Rights · MongoDB Q4 FY24 Earnings Call · MongoDB Q1 FY25 Earnings Call

Experience Revolear

Explore our demos, discover our technology, get a quote, and meet our team—human and AI—in our Virtual Briefing Center.